• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Newcity Stage

Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago

  • Newcity Stage ·
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newcity Network
  • Sections ·
    • Newcity
    • Art
    • Design
    • Film
    • Lit
    • Music
    • Resto
    • Brazil
  • Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Members Hub
Newcity Stage logo

Review: The Butcher of Baraboo/A Red Orchid Theatre

by Zach Freeman | April 11, 2012

by Zach Freeman
April 11, 2012April 11, 2012Filed under:
  • Recommended Shows
  • Theater
  • Theater Reviews

Photo: Michael Brosilow

RECOMMENDED

On the one-year anniversary of her husband’s disappearance, Valerie (Kirsten Fitzgerald) must deal with her shady pharmacist daughter Midge (Missi Davis), her eccentric police-officer sister-in-law Gail (Natalie West) and the new arrivals in the neighborhood—her long-absent brother-in-law Donal (H.B. Ward) and his timid wife Sevenly (Lara Phillips). The rumor in town is that she had a hand in her husband going missing.

Chatting (or, more often, fighting) around the worn dining table in scenic designer Grant Sabin’s perfectly homely working-class kitchen, the characters in Marisa Wegrzyn’s visceral dark comedy feel like they stumbled out of a twisted sitcom world somewhere between “Fargo” and “Roseanne” (and not just because the show-stealing West was a cast member on the latter). Director Shade Murray has his more-than-capable ensemble play it a bit broad throughout, which ups the laughter quotient considerably but makes for a bit of a slowdown whenever things get serious. Still, the show is consistently captivating, with spontaneously funny dialogue and plenty of surprises. (Zach Freeman)

A Red Orchid Theatre, 1531 North Wells, (312)943-8722. $25-$30. Through May 20.

Tagged:
  • A Red Orchid Theatre
  • Grant Sabin
  • H.B. Ward
  • Kirsten Fitzgerald
  • Lara Phillips
  • Marisa Wegrzyn
  • Missi Davis
  • Natalie West
  • Shade Murray

Post navigation

Previous Post Shostakovich, The Musical? Chicago Opera Theater Premieres a Lighthearted Satire by a Serious Composer
Next Post American Blues Theater announces 2012-2013 season
Five women are gathered around a table in a rustic wooden room with bunk beds. One woman stands with hands on hips, while the others sit or stand, engaged in conversation. A sign on the table reads “Property of Serene Pines.”.

Camping with Conspiracy Theorists at A Red Orchid In “The Targeted,” a new play by Hanna Kime, conspiracy theorists gather at a rustic retreat for a meeting of the “Solidarity and Truth Summit.”

Mary Wisniewski May 22, 2026
A modern, multi-story theater building with large glass windows and a vertical sign reading THEATRE. People walk and bike outside, with nearby trees, cars parked, and adjacent urban buildings. A person in glasses is in the foreground.

Stage Top 5: May 2026

Todd Hieggelke May 1, 2026
Two people stand outdoors, looking up. The woman in front holds binoculars and wears a tan jacket, while the man behind her wears a plaid shirt and orange vest, looking up through binoculars. Autumn leaves and a wooden fence are in the background.

“Birds of North America” Takes Flight at A Red Orchid Theatre Anna Ouyang Moench’s father-daughter drama unfolds through birdwatching and climate anxiety.

Mary Wisniewski January 30, 2026
Light bulb lit on stand with various hands and legs coming out of it in different directions.

Stage Top 5: October 2025

Todd Hieggelke October 2, 2025

A magazine cover split vertically: the left half shows wood grain, the right half shows a mans face and neck. NEWCITY and OCTOBER 2021 appear in yellow text at the top right.

October Issue
Realism

GET A COPY

SUBSCRIBE

White text in all capital letters on a light gray background spells NEWCITY..
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Chicago Film Project

Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc. © 2026