• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Newcity Stage

Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago

  • Newcity Stage ·
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newcity Network
  • Sections ·
    • Newcity
    • Art
    • Design
    • Film
    • Lit
    • Music
    • Resto
    • Brazil
  • Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
Newcity Stage logo

Review: The Strange Undoing of Prudencia Hart/Chicago Shakespeare Theater

by Brian Hieggelke | September 28, 2012

by Brian Hieggelke
September 28, 2012October 1, 2012Filed under:
  • Recommended Shows
  • Theater Reviews

Melody Grove, Andrew Clark, Annie Grace/Photo: Drew Farrell

RECOMMENDED

Coming to Chicago all the way from the National Theatre of Scotland, “The Strange Undoing of Prudencia Hart” features a fine set of musicians and actors acting out one devil of a tale. Complete with fiddles, drums and other folk-centered instruments, the cast sings and acts out the story of one Prudencia Hart, a professor as prudish as her name. After attending a tedious conference in remote Kelso, she finds herself snowed in at a pub. Although at first excited at the opportunity to record traditional folk music at this Scottish Borders town, she is aghast to find that karaoke here is the music of choice.  Worse, she is trapped at the bar with her nemesis, a self-absorbed professor of folk who preaches the virtues of modern tastes.  When the locals become bawdy, Prudencia looks for a way out and finds herself in the company of the devil himself.

Given the wonderful Highland music strummed throughout the performance as well as the readily available liquor, the story here is much better than it has to be. In addition to some genuine suspense, the audience is treated to the most unique vision of hell this side of Sartre. Never will I look at a bed and breakfast in quite the same way. Acting here is also topnotch with Melody Grove making a very convincing Prudencia. David McKay’s performance also more than gives the devil his due. But it is the music that really sets the mood and transforms the Chicago Shakespeare upstairs theater into a happening pub. I did not even mind the audience participation and found myself waving my arms along with everyone else during the final crucial scenes. I did hold out, however, to the benefit of everyone around me, on the singing. (Noel Schecter)

Chicago Shakespeare Theater, 800 East Grand (Navy Pier), (312)595-5600. Through October 28.

Tagged:
  • Chicago Shakespeare Theater
  • David McKay
  • Melody Grove
  • National Theatre of Scotland

Post navigation

Previous Post Review: HooDoo Love/Collective Theatre
Next Post Kinky Boots Kicks The Press: Taking in the Cyndi Lauper and Harvey Fierstein Show
A group of actors in period costumes perform a dramatic scene on an outdoor stage with green steps and medieval-style banners; one man stands in front, looking pensive, while others watch or kneel behind him.

American Players Theatre’s Wondrous “As You Like It,” Staged in the Woods In Shakespeare's comedy, the characters go to the forest and become more fully human. The same thing happens when you see theater in the woods at Spring Green, Wisconsin.

Mary Wisniewski July 24, 2026
An older man in a suit stands triumphantly with a sword raised, foot on the back of a young man lying face down on a living room floor, with elegant furniture and bookshelves in the background.

“Fault” Is in the Scars: Battling Couple Comedy Crackles and Cracks Jason Alexander directs this world premiere at Chicago Shakespeare Theater, a “marital combat” play with tightly wound action that takes repeated shots at the intimate lives of its coupled characters.

Ted C. Fishman April 30, 2026
A woman in a maroon dress confronts a bearded man in a red robe who is kneeling on top of a large wicker chest. In the background, two other people embrace near a white couch on a modern stage set.

Shakespeare’s Raucous Farce Is Filled with Puns, Pratfalls and Pleasures Chicago Shakespeare Theater stages "The Merry Wives of Windsor," a comedy that is produced less often than others in the Bard's canon, but worth catching.

Ted C. Fishman April 13, 2026
Two people in period costumes smile closely together; the man wears a dark blue jacket, while the woman wears a floral crown and yellow dress. They appear joyful and intimate, possibly in a wedding or festive scene.

The Royal Shakespeare Company’s “Hamnet” Shows How Grief Inspires Art The lead character in this U.S. premiere at Chicago Shakes is not the playwright, but his wife, Agnes. The play is about her union with the Bard and the family they create, as well as Will’s attempt to resurrect a beloved lost child through his art.

Mary Wisniewski February 18, 2026

Newcity cover showing woman with red hair and bird-face, with nest and crow on top of head.

September Issue
Fall Arts + Art 50

GET A COPY

SUBSCRIBE

NewcityLogo.png
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Chicago Film Project

Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc. © 2026