• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Newcity Stage

Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago

  • Newcity Stage ·
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newcity Network
  • Sections ·
    • Newcity
    • Art
    • Design
    • Film
    • Lit
    • Music
    • Resto
    • Brazil
  • Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
Newcity Stage logo

Review: It’s a Wonderful Life: Live in Chicago!/American Blues Theater

by Zach Freeman | November 25, 2013

by Zach Freeman
November 25, 2013November 25, 2013Filed under:
  • Christmas
  • Holiday
  • Recommended Shows
  • Theater
  • Theater Reviews
Photo by Johnny Knight

Photo: Johnny Knight

RECOMMENDED

Despite the fact that it’s been a Chicago holiday tradition for more than a decade (first produced in 2002) and its source material is a 1946 film, every moment of American Blues Theater’s current production of “It’s a Wonderful Life: Live in Chicago!” feels fresh and new, with the eager ensemble (led by original director Marty Higginbotham) throwing themselves into the story with so much wide-eyed gusto you can’t help but feel pulled in—into the story itself and into the general life-affirming message of how it is, in fact, a wonderful life.

American Blues Theater presents it as a live radio show in the 1940s and scenic designer Grant Sabin has created a cozy, idealized radio-station recording studio of a set, with snow occasionally falling outside a window and (in case you didn’t know this was a Christmas show) not one, not two, but three fully decorated Christmas trees springing up across the stage. Announcer and pianist Michael Mahler drives the show forward, both narratively and musically, while Foley artist Shawn J. Goudie creates a soundscape that adds depth and texture to the reading.

Kevin R. Kelly and Gwendolyn Whiteside/Photo by Johnny Knight

Kevin R. Kelly and Gwendolyn Whiteside/Photo: Johnny Knight

The other six cast members embody the rest of the characters in the story, alternately stepping up to one of the three microphones at the front of the stage to deliver their dialogue and advance the tale of the goodhearted George Bailey (the captivating Kevin R. Kelly) and his dreams and struggles in the small town of Bedford Falls as he tries to keep his late father’s business afloat despite the pressures of conniving businessman Mr. Potter (John Mohrlein, serving double duty on the other side of the goodness spectrum as Clarence the angel).

Catchy jingles for actual Chicago companies are sprinkled into two “commercial breaks” and touching “audiograms” written by audience members before the show are read out as well (a few were so poignant I started to suspect they were pre-written, but afterward a friend told me theirs was read).

The show is uncompromisingly heartfelt and genuine, which risks it coming across as hokey (or even campy) in our rather cynical times. But the story holds up well and, especially during the holiday season, a well-meaning dose of unadulterated optimism is welcome medicine. Running only ninety minutes with no intermission, the show opens and closes with Christmas sing-alongs and the entire audience is offered post-show cookies and milk. This earnest family-friendly production offers the perfect jolt of holiday spirit for audiences of all ages. (Zach Freeman)

American Blues Theater at the Greenhouse Theater Center, 2257 North Lincoln, (773)404-7336. americanbluestheater.com. $19-$49. Through December 29.

Tagged:
  • American Blues Theater
  • Grant Sabin
  • Greenhouse Theater Center
  • John Möhrlein
  • Kevin R. Kelly
  • Marty Higginbotham
  • Michael Mahler
  • Shawn J. Goudie

Post navigation

Previous Post Review: Burning Bluebeard/The Ruffians
Next Post Review: La traviata/Lyric Opera
A person wearing a bow tie, suspenders, and a cape holds a microphone and performs on stage, gesturing expressively with one hand against a dark background.

Couch Penny Ensemble’s Solid “An Oak Tree” Plays With Our Mind While Stirring Our Feelings Tim Crouch’s 2006 melancholic memory play about loss and healing features two outstanding performances, one of them unrehearsed.

Hugh Iglarsh June 25, 2026
Two women sit on a beige couch; one comforts the other who leans on her shoulder. In the foreground, a missing person flyer, wine bottle, and two empty glasses sit on a table. The scene feels tense and emotional.

In a Dog-Eat-Dog World, It’s Not Easy Being Human Ego Death Theatre Collective’s sure-handed production of “A Dog’s House” shows the impact of a pet’s violent death on the owners’ relationships.

Hugh Iglarsh June 3, 2026
A woman in a sparkly dress and white gloves sings into a vintage microphone on stage, lit by a spotlight, with a drum set and musicians in the background.

The Music Is Memorable in “Always … Patsy Cline,” the Framing Story Not So Much Liz Chidester gives a terrific star turn as the country music legend, but the American Blues Theater production of this warhorse jukebox musical keeps us at arm’s length from Patsy as a person.

Hugh Iglarsh May 14, 2026
A modern, multi-story theater building with large glass windows and a vertical sign reading THEATRE. People walk and bike outside, with nearby trees, cars parked, and adjacent urban buildings. A person in glasses is in the foreground.

Stage Top 5: May 2026

Todd Hieggelke May 1, 2026

Newcity cover showing woman with red hair and bird-face, with nest and crow on top of head.

September Issue
Fall Arts + Art 50

GET A COPY

SUBSCRIBE

NewcityLogo.png
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Chicago Film Project

Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc. © 2026