• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Newcity Stage

Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago

  • Newcity Stage ·
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newcity Network
  • Sections ·
    • Newcity
    • Art
    • Design
    • Film
    • Lit
    • Music
    • Resto
    • Brazil
  • Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
Newcity Stage logo

Review: The New Sincerity/Theater Wit

by Irene Hsiao | March 11, 2016

by Irene Hsiao
March 11, 2016June 15, 2016Filed under:
  • Theater
  • Theater Reviews
Photo: Charles Osgood

Maura Kidwell and Drew Shirley/Photo: Charles Osgood

RECOMMENDED

Like every television show ever made about life in New York City, Alena Smith’s “The New Sincerity” occurs in an improbably excellent piece of real estate: a split-level loft apartment with windows overlooking Zuccotti Park, furnished with kitchenette, vintage leather couch, communal dining area and shared work space with ample natural light. It rapidly unfolds that the joint is bankrolled by the father of the absent co-editor of Asymptote, a literary magazine with aspirations to become the next Partisan Review. The time is autumn of 2011, the occasion the heady heyday and decline of Occupy, the movement/protest/lifestyle that briefly became the object of the utopianism, skepticism and confusion felt for and by the millennial generation.

The drama of the movement, without the squalor of actually having to camp in the park, is enacted in the safe confines of the apartment, where Asymptote editor Benjamin (Drew Shirley)—who is not the main character but, as the white man with power, might as well be—is torn between his desire for rising political writer Rose (Maura Kidwell), his neoconservative fiancée Sadie, a Fulbright scholar who has just completed a book on the failure of the Left, and young intern Natasha (Erin Long), a chirpy, lissome product of internet culture who emits commentary at tweet-speed and effortlessly inhabits the frenetic gymnastics of real and virtual life.

The real protagonist, à la “The Devil Wears Prada,” is, of course, the introspective, secretly beautiful Rose, a graduate student writing her dissertation on romantic irony in Stendhal. Rose sublimates her sentiments about Occupy into her own amorous yearnings which alternate between sex in a tent with a shirtless-but-not-shoeless artist, occupier and espouser of free love named Django (Alex Stein) and repressed desires for her boss whom she hopes will leave Sadie and legitimately articulate a respectful and genuinely felt love for her.

Smart, well-acted and slickly produced, with a soundtrack that includes CeeLo Green and Rihanna, “The New Sincerity” captures the spirit of an age lightly lived and easily forgotten, which strives for a significance and a magnitude that won’t be easily achieved. (Irene Hsiao)

Theater Wit, 1229 West Belmont, (773)975-8150, theaterwit.org, $12-$36. Through April 17.

Tagged:
  • Alena Smith
  • Alex Stein
  • Drew Shirley
  • Erin Long
  • Maura Kidwell
  • Theater Wit

Post navigation

Previous Post Review: Richard III/The Gift Theatre
Next Post Review: Burn/Mercy Street Theatre Company
Three people sit on the floor around a bed, laughing and drinking together in a cozy, colorful room with rugs, pillows, and a dresser. Empty chairs line the wall, and a photo is taped to a white door in the background.

The Teenagers in “Adolescent Salvation” Are Not Just Kids The Chicago premiere of Tim Venable's play starts as a Zoomer screwball and ends as an indictment of the way adults fail to protect their children.

Rob Silverman Ascher August 31, 2026
Two performers, one wearing a large theatrical mask and carrying a suitcase, embrace warmly on a dimly lit stage with dark brick walls in the background.

From Dance to Circus: A Riotous Journey with Physical Theater Festival The annual festival brings many performance types under its umbrella.

Sharon Hoyer May 27, 2026
A young person with long hair, wearing shorts, leaps energetically off a sandy hill, silhouetted against a clear blue sky with trees in the background.

Dance Top 5: June 2026

Sharon Hoyer May 26, 2026
A black and white photo of a person lying motionless on a table, partially covered by a sheet, in a dark and empty room. A spotlight illuminates the body, emphasizing a somber and dramatic atmosphere.

“The Shape of the Bones” Has Promise but Needs To Be Fleshed Out Playwright Spencer Huffman’s religious drama—and New Theatre Project’s first production in a conventional theater space—boasts some excellent performances in a story that doesn’t quite satisfy.

Hugh Iglarsh March 6, 2026

Newcity cover showing woman with red hair and bird-face, with nest and crow on top of head.

September Issue
Fall Arts + Art 50

GET A COPY

SUBSCRIBE

NewcityLogo.png
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Chicago Film Project

Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc. © 2026