• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Newcity Stage

Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago

  • Newcity Stage ·
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newcity Network
  • Sections ·
    • Newcity
    • Art
    • Design
    • Film
    • Lit
    • Music
    • Resto
    • Brazil
  • Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
Newcity Stage logo

Blurred New World: A Review of Pilgrims at The Gift Theatre

by Danielle Levsky | July 11, 2017

by Danielle Levsky
July 11, 2017July 11, 2017Filed under:
  • Recommended Shows
  • Theater
  • Theater Reviews
  • World Premiere

Janelle Villas, Brittany Burch and Ed Flynn/Photo: Claire Demos

RECOMMENDED

In sci-fi narratives, there is often the potential to succumb to the setting, technology and implications of a futuristic/apocalyptic era. While “Pilgrims” finds the perfect balance of creating this world for the viewer, there are still ambiguities in the characters’ own histories that leave the audience wanting.

The design team behind this spacecraft headed to colonize a new planet is impeccable: Arnel Sancianco’s minimalistic set and electronic displays, Alexandra Main’s muted props, Christopher Kriz’s subtle and penetrating sound and Heather Gilbert’s careful mood lighting all recall “2001: A Space Odyssey” and “Star Trek.”

Michael Patrick Thornton and Jessica Thebus’ co-direction gives space in a confined room for all three actors to explore their personas entirely. Brittany Burch, who plays the outdated, seventies-airline-stewardess-inspired robot Jasmine, is a mechanical wonder to behold. Her physicality, expressions and speech are artificially human; she is haunting and exciting to watch. When the Soldier (Ed Flynn) and the Girl (Janelle Villas) rely on her for human comfort, the audience understands and believes she can be real.

A delightful illusion.

Flynn and Villas are both powerful forces to be reckoned with. Trapped on board this cabin, their suffocation is tangible in degrees. Flynn plays out the demons of his character’s past in every movement. His haggard gaze, coupled with his verbal and physical delivery, drips with sweat, PTSD, disillusionment and pain. Villas’ delivery demonstrates different, yet equally complex, coping mechanisms; the Girl is tenacious and hides her own trauma behind make-believe games and a bubbly personality. Their vulnerabilities strike every chord.

While the designers, directors and actors create the heartbreaking, relevant and touching world that is “Pilgrims,” it is Claire Kiechel’s script itself that feels like it is missing something. The complexity and confusion in the story behind interplanetary colonization is never easy. However, in this case the vagueness is present in the pasts of the Soldier and Girl. Their stories are told in bits and pieces; some parts feel relevant, while others are hazy or extraneous. Toward the end of the show, the script starts to flicker like the potentially compromised programming aboard the ship. There is one disturbing and, frankly, unnecessary physical assault scene that neither brings the characters closer together nor does it tear them apart. The walls that they break down with this scene are abrupt and unnatural, almost like they are rushing to the final line of the play. This brave new world quickly becomes a blurred new world, though the potential for clarity and understanding is potent. (Danielle Levsky)

The Gift Theatre, 4802 North Milwaukee, thegifttheatre.org, $20-$40. Through July 30.

Tagged:
  • Alexandra Main
  • Arnel Sancianco
  • Brittany Burch
  • Christopher Kriz
  • Claire Kiechel
  • Ed Flynn
  • Heather Gilbert
  • Janelle Villas
  • Jessica Thebus
  • Michael Patrick Thornton
  • review
  • The Gift Theatre

Post navigation

Previous Post On Stage and In the Mind: A Review of The Nance at Pride Films and Plays
Next Post Raw, Ambitious, Passionate, Imperfect
Two men in suits stand in a room with arched ceilings, facing a seated woman. Another person sits in the background at a table. The scene is dimly lit with lamps and chandeliers.

Gift Theatre’s “Marble” Starts Strong Before Going Cold and Hard Endings are never easy, but rarely does a play that begins so well move so decisively in the wrong direction as does Marina Carr’s 2009 work, an Irish dramedy that’s almost salvaged by a quartet of powerful performances.

Hugh Iglarsh August 7, 2026
A woman in a Victorian dress points a knife at a seated man with his hands tied behind his back in an ornate, antique room with wooden furniture and a staircase in the background.

Northlight’s “Gaslight” Turns One Husband’s Manipulation Into a Victorian Detective Caper If you feel like a little malice for the holiday season, catch the triumphantly feminist drama that coined a term prevalent in modern politics.

Mary Wisniewski December 10, 2025
Actors in period costumes perform a scene in an elegant drawing room set, featuring a Christmas tree, a piano, and ornate furniture. Three women converse in front, while two men and a woman sit and talk at the back.

“Georgiana and Kitty: Christmas at Pemberley” Returns to the World of Jane Austen Buffalo Theatre Ensemble's play, set during the 1815 Christmas season at the Pemberley estate in England, addresses feminist issues of equality and agency.

Tristan Bruns December 4, 2025
An actor in Victorian garb stares out from the foreground of a stage.

The Best of Times: A Review of “A Tale of Two Cities” at Shattered Globe Theatre

Tristan Bruns May 5, 2025

A magazine cover split vertically: the left half shows wood grain, the right half shows a mans face and neck. NEWCITY and OCTOBER 2021 appear in yellow text at the top right.

October Issue
Realism

GET A COPY

SUBSCRIBE

White text in all capital letters on a light gray background spells NEWCITY..
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Chicago Film Project

Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc. © 2026