Mariusz Kwiecien, Marina Rebeka, Matthew Polenzani/ Photo: Andrew Cioffi
RECOMMENDED
Plenty of people have quibbled about Bizet’s problem child, “Les pêcheurs de perles.” After its initial eighteen performances, this opera was sent away for a very long time. Even Bizet didn’t like it. Only Berlioz went on the record as liking the piece but we must consider that he could be a contrarian and might have been having one off the wrist in the general direction of the French musical intelligentsia.
Nevertheless, the opera is growing in popularity, particularly in the United States and especially in Chicago, following its airing during Lyric’s 2008-2009 season, featuring the naked torsos of Eric Cutler and Nathan Gunn. I understand that they sang nicely, too. Since others have quibbled in general, I will quibble specifically: Lyric’s current production finds the singers at odds with the direction, as they attempt to simulate physicality with each other that is so clearly inorganic individually and collectively that we have no choice but to blame the director. The dancers, none without charm and ability, are unevenly matched in style, to the point where we must blame those connected with the casting and rehearsing of this ad hoc troop.
All the rest of it is just plain gorgeous. Marina Rebeka (Leïla), Matthew Polenzani (Nadir) and Mariusz Kwiecien (Zurga) all sing this lovely music with exactly the right style, particularly in that every phrase passes through a rock-solid, melting mezza voce. These three artists give every moment its beginning, middle and end, and in the appropriate order. Further, their techniques are so well-honed that this gentle melding of vocal registers is always audible, even in Lyric’s cavernous temple. Polenzani’s first aria is floated so hauntingly that he never reaches a true forte, because his soul-searching of the fledgling Bizet’s melody doesn’t call for it.
Go to hear the famous tenor and baritone duet—you know it even if you think you don’t—and stay for a fairytale of love gone awry. You’ll be too lifted out of yourself to quibble. (Aaron Hunt)
Lyric Opera of Chicago, 20 North Upper Wacker, (312)332-2244, lyricopera.org, $20-$299. Through December 10
Related Stories
How To Not Train Your Dragon: A Review of Siegfried at Lyric Opera of Chicago The "but"s keep coming in Lyric Opera's latest installment of Wagner's Ring Cycle.- Fundamental Sound: A Review of Ariodante at Lyric Opera of Chicago Nearly three hundred years since its premiere, Handel's opera of desire and power gains insight and urgency in this modern staging.
- The Next Episode: A Review of Die Walküre at Lyric Opera of Chicago The second installment of Lyric's Ring Cycle stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the first.
- Children of War: A Review of Elektra at Lyric Opera of Chicago The latest from Lyric Opera examines the consequences of national and international conflict on the lives and well-being of children.
- Tears of a Clown: A Review of Rigoletto at Lyric Opera of Chicago Verdi's tragic opera is lightened by standout performances from veterans and newcomers alike.
- Predators and Prey: A Review of Turandot at Lyric Opera of Chicago Puccini's tale of misogyny and sexism finds deep resonance in 2017.
