C. Jaye Miller and Scottie Caldwell/Photo: Joe Mazza
Babes With Blade’s new show “The Good Fight” sounds incredibly exciting at first glance: suffragettes whi are crusading for the right to vote in England learn jiu jitsu from their “chorus-girl” friends and kick English bobby tush. How could this not be exactly the women-kicking-butt-and-taking-names play we’ve all been waiting for?
Well.
It’s not that “The Good Fight” is bad, necessarily. The actors are passionate and that passion translates into some lovely performances. But the script is plodding, the plot lacks an arc, every plot progression is so dramatic that no plot progression is dramatic, and the end of the play feels much like the beginning, leaving the audience to wonder, “Wait. But why?”
Alas, this play’s main fault is that it is boring: a fact brought into sharp relief by its potential to be anything but. I couldn’t help but imagine how much more gripping it would have been if the plot had centered more closely on The Suffragette Bodyguard (the group of women who learned jiu jitsu to protect their leader from the police), if they hadn’t taken so long to get to the jiu jitsu and then spent such little time on it. Or if they had included a plot point centering on one of the many South Asian British suffragettes, without whom English women would never have gained the vote and whose history is so often thoughtlessly erased and disregarded. Or even if they’d simply narrowed the history the play attempts to show and chosen the specificity of a single story rather than the attempt at seven disjointed ones.
There’s nothing to separate this play from a thousand other narratives about the British Suffrage movement. There’s nothing to separate it from the controversial film “Suffragette” that came out a few years ago. There’s nothing to separate it from the more melodramatic episodes of “Downton Abbey.” It’s linear, traditional theater that takes very little risk for linear, traditional folks who wish to be comfortable.
On the night I went, at the end of the play the narrator leaned forward with stars in her eyes and informed the audience that “All women got the right to vote in 1928.”
I winced.
She means Englishwomen, of course. White American women gained suffrage in 1920, Asian-American women gained it in 1952 and non-Asian women of color didn’t gain it until the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s, a fact often forgotten. But to assert that all British women gained the vote in 1928 is wrong too. Citizens of the Commonwealth of Nations didn’t gain voting rights until 1981, a mere thirty-seven years ago.
To state that The Representation of the People (Equal Franchise) Act of 1928 in British Parliament was the end of the British suffrage movement is a colonized version of history, and it’s heartbreaking to see colonized history propagated through art. I expected more from one of our city’s feminist theater companies. (Emma Couling)
Babes With Blades Theatre Company at City Lit Theater Company, 1020 West Bryn Mawr, babeswithblades.org, $15-$25. Through February 17.
Related Stories
Beyond the Glass Ceiling: A Review of Women of 4G at Babes With Blades Theatre Company This sci-fi original is part classic murder-mystery, part probing workplace drama. - Heaven Made Her Such a Man: A Review of Othello at Babes with Blades Theatre Company This production's all-female cast succeeds in focusing a play often seen through the lens of race quite pointedly upon gender.
- Scots on the Run: A Review of Midsummer (A Play with Songs) at Greenhouse Theater Center and Proxy Theatre The Midwest premiere of this "play with songs" bills itself as the Scottish "Once." And it delivers.
- Fight or Flight: A Review of Escapes & Reversals at Unity Lutheran Church Ginger Krebs' new hourlong performance shows us a game in which the current winner is the moneyed, narrative-owning powers that be, but the underdog team, though skittish and sustaining damage, can still reveal truth.
- Between a Saint and a Sinner: A Review of Good Enough at 16th Street Theater This simple but hardly straightforward world premiere finds one woman speaking her truth with honesty and self-reflection.
- Nothing Either Good or Bad: A Review of Hamlet at Chicago Shakespeare Theater Directed by Barbara Gaines, CST's production meets but does not exceed expectations.
The claim that there were “many South Asian British suffragettes” is factually incorrect. There was, in reality, exactly one South Asian suffragette, namely Princess Sophia Duleep Singh. There were Indian women (living in India) who supported the suffrage campaign and who were photographed marching in a pro-suffrage parade, but they were not suffragettes. That term is (and was) specific to the members and active supporters of Mrs. Pankhurst’s radical Women’s Social and Political Union, including Princess Sophia who supported the WSPU financially and participated in some of their demonstrations.