Matthew Huston and John Marshall Jr./Photo: Paul Goyette
“Yank,” the feel-good World War II romantic musical currently playing at Pride Films and Plays, feels in every way familiar. It would fit in the canon of forties musicals to which it pays homage but for one significant difference. It tells a story that would never have been told in 1945, of the gay men who joined the military in that era.
In “Yank,” Stu (Matthew Huston) is drafted into the military and introduced to the gay underground by a photographer who recruits him to work for YANK, an Army magazine. But Stu’s feelings for a fellow private lead to a seemingly inevitable and horrific imprisonment.
It’s a nice play and it should be appreciated for what it achieves. Every gay kid who grew up watching Fred Astaire, Gene Kelly and Danny Kaye now have a musical that tells their story and the story of the gay men who came before them, complete with a show-stopping tap number in the first act. The performers do a lovely job. The script and music may lack originality, but they achieve what they set out to achieve.
It’s the sort of play that Pride Films and Plays can bank on: clever, on-brand, and on-mission. But this new musical still features elements of classical musical theater that we could live without, the seemingly unending song in act one wherein the fellas in Stu’s squad wax poetic about the pin-up girls whose photos they have stored in their pockets being chief. I understand the plot progression of expressing that Stu feels left out of toxic-masculine heteronormativity but that could have been achieved in a brief moment of dialogue rather than the four minutes of sexism that all the women in the audience have to sit through. Future iterations of this show could consider making an agreement with the writers to cut that song.
It was also disappointing to see another majority-white cast that featured only one woman. It felt eerily like watching those old forties musicals but perhaps not in the way that Pride Films and Plays intended. (Emma Couling)
Pride Films and Plays, 4139 North Broadway, pridefilmsandplays.com, $30-$40. Through February 18.
Related Stories
The Name’s The Thing: A Review of It’s Only a Play at Pride Films and Plays A redux of Terrance McNally's less-than-successful "Broadway, Broadway," Pride Films and Plays' production reminds us just what's in a name: quite a lot.- On Stage and In the Mind: A Review of The Nance at Pride Films and Plays RECOMMENDED Douglas Carter Beane’s script tells the story of 1930s burlesque performers at Irving Place Theatre in New York City, focusing on Chauncey Miles (Vince Kracht), who is known for his onstage role as a "nance"—a camp, stock character who is often effeminate. Kracht is able to juggle the complexity of Chauncey delicately and with ease. Chauncey may play a…
- SoCo in Time: A Review of Southern Comfort at Pride Films and Plays This heartfelt new musical feels like the first signs of spring: hopeful and encouraging.
- A Coming Out Christmas: A Review of Barney the Elf at Pride Films and Plays Now in its fourth year, this Chicago-originating musical, based on the movie "Elf," moves to Pride Films and Plays, losing none of its willful cheer.
- Hooks and Hook-Ups: A Review of Grindr The Opera at Pride Films and Plays Sitting on the fence between camp and cautionary tale, this rock opera unveils a world of love and lust that is more finger-to-finger than face-to-face.
- Flawlessly Deployed: A Review of The CiviliTy of Albert Cashier at Permoveo Production/Pride Films and Plays A thoroughly American story, not only because it canonizes an American soldier, an immigrant and an outsider but also because it adheres to narratives dear to the American spirit.
