• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Newcity Stage

Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago

  • Newcity Stage ·
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newcity Network
  • Sections ·
    • Newcity
    • Art
    • Design
    • Film
    • Lit
    • Music
    • Resto
    • Brazil
  • Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
Newcity Stage logo

Shake a Spear: A Review of Something Rotten! at Marriott Theatre

by Noel Schecter | September 17, 2019

by Noel Schecter
September 17, 2019September 27, 2019Filed under:
  • Midwest Premiere
  • Theater
  • Theater Reviews

The cast of “Something Rotten”/Photo: Liz Lauren

There is nothing rotten at all in Lincolnshire. In fact, most people will find this Marriott Theatre production of “Something Rotten!” to be quite delightful. Nominated for ten Tony Awards, this 2015 musical comedy takes aim at everything from the Renaissance to Shakespeare to “Cats.” This production also offers some truly brilliant choreography by Alex Sanchez and is even performed in the round. Methinks Shakespeare would approve.

Set in 1595, the musical focuses on a budding rivalry between the Bottom Brothers (a pair of struggling playwrights) and a certain Will Shakespeare. Portrayed as an obnoxious rockstar, Shakespeare (Adam Jacobs) finds it easier to plagiarize others than to sit down and write a new play. The two brothers have their own ideas. The older of the two, Nick (KJ Hippensteel), has Thomas Nostradamus (cousin to the more famous Nostradamus) foretell Shakespeare’s future greatest hit, with the thought that he can then preemptively steal it. And while this Nostradamus can predict the advent of musicals (as well as several big titles), he misidentifies Shakespeare’s next masterpiece as “Omelet.” Undaunted, Nick takes this shell of an idea and runs with it. The end result is a mishmash play like no other that manages to fit the highlights of a dozen or so musicals into the framework of a classic Shakespearean tragedy.

“Something Rotten!” is a good play that, when performed by this exceptionally talented cast, approaches being a great play. While rarely hilarious, there are laugh-out-loud moments. And the dancing is absolutely sublime. One weakness is the inoffensive nature of the script, which lacks both the silliness of “Spamalot” or the raunchiness of “Avenue Q.” The music too, while competent, lacks that one big breakout number, although “God, I Hate Shakespeare” comes close. That is not to say that “Something Rotten!” is not worth seeing. But if you plan on only seeing one musical comedy this year, it might make more sense waiting for “Book of Mormon” to come back to town. (Noel Schecter)

Marriott Theatre, 10 Marriott Drive, Lincolnshire, (847)634-0200, marriotttheatre.com, $50-$60. Through October 20.

Tagged:
  • Adam Jacobs
  • Alex Sanchez
  • Marriott Theatre

Post navigation

Previous Post Life and Liberty: A Review of Be Here Now at Shattered Globe Theatre
Next Post Fall Arts Preview 2019: This is What America Looks Like: Cerqua Rivera Dance Theatre digs deep into identity and the immigrant experience
Eight people stand and sit on yellow scaffolding onstage, some wearing safety vests, under dramatic lighting, with dark background and blue spotlight. They look intensely toward the camera.

“Come From Away” on the Twenty-Fifth Anniversary of 9/11 Marriott Theatre's beautiful and highly relevant production celebrates the heroic efforts of everyday citizens who welcome and help heal those devastated by national events.

Noel Schecter September 14, 2026

Isn’t It Rich To Experience Sondheim in the Round? The Marriott Theatre's "A Little Night Music" is an optimistic operetta.

Dennis Polkow July 8, 2026
A waiter wears a white tux with a life jacket over it, looking up in fear.

Dream Ship of Nightmares: A Review of “Titanic: The Musical” at Marriott Theatre

Dennis Polkow April 25, 2025

A New Dream Will Do: A Review of “Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat” at Marriott Theatre

Dennis Polkow March 10, 2025

A magazine cover split vertically: the left half shows wood grain, the right half shows a mans face and neck. NEWCITY and OCTOBER 2021 appear in yellow text at the top right.

October Issue
Realism

GET A COPY

SUBSCRIBE

White text in all capital letters on a light gray background spells NEWCITY..
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Chicago Film Project

Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc. © 2026