Choose Adventure: A Review of Season Pass: Deux Over at The Plagiarists

Charlotte Long, Stephen McClure/Photo: Joe Mazza at Brave Lux

Upon first inspection, “Season Pass: Deux Over” might look like it was put together at the last minute. One step into the Jarvis Square Theatre and you’re met with cardboard sets and a haphazard aesthetic. But when you take a closer look, you see the time and ingenuity that was put into this production, five years in the making. Written by The Plagiarists through a company-based creative process, “Season Pass: Deux Over” is a revival of their original choose-your-own-adventure show, “Season Pass” from their 2014 season. Directed by Paul Kastner and Nick Freed, the production proves that looks can be deceiving. “Season Pass: Deux Over” is actually an expertly crafted experience for anyone’s inner child. 

The Plagiarists fulfill their namesake and pull from many sources to create a new yet strangely familiar landscape. The story, set and characters come from vintage Disneyland rides, first-person video games, 1950s science-fiction B-movies and human history. You can tell that directors Freed and Kastner have a background in commedia dell’arte because every character portrays a different stock type: the absent-minded professor (à la Doc Brown in “Back to the Future” or Rick Sanchez from “Rick & Morty”), the tough military colonel, the salty sea captain. They play integral parts in the story even if you don’t know how until you get there. 

Despite recognizable character types, the dialogue and acting are unpredictable. The production understands the importance of atmosphere toward a comprehensive experience. The actors, in whatever roles they’re playing, are committed and have a continuous flow through the visual effects and audience-induced changes in course. Background players and puppeteers are captivating and help engage the audience in the absurd realms we’re led into. Nick Freed’s sea-dog captain and Charlotte Long’s first mate form a hilarious partnership that has that rare combination of dynamism and rhythm that is typically only found within the scope of live theater.

The low-budget, handmade aesthetic makes “Season Pass: Deux Over” feel like wandering into the elaborate playhouse of a little kid. The intentionally shabby set (designed by Melissa Schlesinger and Nina D’Angier) matches the apocalyptic conditions the characters set out, but the craftsmanship and design follow the hopeful (or naive) mindset of a child. Can we (as an audience) really save the world? This brand of ingenuity continues with the construction of aquatic puppets (James Snyder) from recycled materials and the use of red bedsheets to simulate internal organs. The creativity of the set and props complement the lights (Charles Blunt) and sound effects (Sarah Espinoza), which support the narrative by simply keeping you in the world of improbability. 

The communal experience you will share with your fellow viewers during this production is energizing. The performance I attended had an attentive crowd and every time we made a choice the excitement or disappointment was mutual. After the show, audience members remarked on their delight when their choice reflected the majority. They felt like they had truly influenced and participated in the show. Besides opening-night jitters and a few characters tripping over their lines, “Season Pass: Deux Over” is a playful joyride that I would board again. Especially since whatever the night and whatever the crowd, you’re sure to get a one-of-a-kind adventure. (Hayley Osborn) 

The Plagiarists at Jarvis Square Theatre, 1439 West Jarvis, theplagiarists.org, Pay-What-You-Can. Through October 5.