• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Newcity Stage

Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago

  • Newcity Stage ·
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newcity Network
  • Sections ·
    • Newcity
    • Art
    • Design
    • Film
    • Lit
    • Music
    • Resto
    • Brazil
  • Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Members Hub
Newcity Stage logo

Through the Holiday Looking-Glass: A Review of “Becoming Santa Claus” at Chicago Opera Theater

by Dennis Polkow | December 15, 2021

by Dennis Polkow
December 15, 2021December 15, 2021Filed under:
  • Christmas
  • Recommended Opera
  • Recommended Shows

“Becoming Santa Claus” with Justin Berkowitz, Matt Boehler, Martin Bakari, Leah Dexter and Amy Owens

RECOMMENDED

Ballet companies have their Nutcrackers, theater companies have Ebenezer Scrooge, but what does an opera company do for the holidays?

There’s always Humperdinck’s “Hansel and Gretel,” often presented as a children’s Christmas opera, albeit a dark telling. Victor Herbert’s fairytale operetta “Babes in Toyland” was once a holiday staple but has fallen into obscurity. Menotti’s “Amahl and the Night Visitors” was written as a Christmas opera for television which means its hour length is only a holiday hors d’oeuvre when performed.

Kudos to composer-librettist Mark Adamo for tackling the idea of writing a Christmas opera that attempts to fill that void and to Chicago Opera Theater for presenting this all-new, second-ever production of Adamo’s 2015 “Becoming Santa Claus.”

The title is misleading in that this is not an epic sung saga on the centuries-long mythologizing of St. Nicholas. This is holiday fiction so outside of temporality that its Santa character can have star-chasing magi as relatives despite a near three-century gap between these figures.

The kingdom where “Becoming Santa Claus” is set is far north. The attire, harpsichord and florid singing suggest eighteenth century, but the sumptuous orchestral score is unabashed romanticism albeit with contemporary touches such as two pianos respectively tuned a quarter tone flat and sharp.

Did I mention all the characters are elves and that the climactic aria is sung by a donkey? If this all sounds as if we’ve gone through the holiday looking-glass, Adamo, astonishingly, pulls it off.

Tenor Martin Bakari makes a youthful and exuberant Prince Claus, spoiled to the core by his mother Queen Sophine, mezzo-soprano Nina Yoshida Nelson. Both roles are technically demanding and each also make a dramatic journey that is central to the climactic payoff.

No less significant is the role of the Donkey/Messenger, bass David Salsbery Fry, who movingly delivers an animal’s account of the Nativity.

Soprano Amy Owens pulls off an elfin entrance to a high E-flat and assorted enchanting elves include mezzo-soprano Leah Dexter, tenor Justin Berkowitz and bass Matt Boehler. Things are kept moving with momentum by director-choreographer Kyle Lang.

The orchestra is in many ways the star of the production—sometimes literally in portraying the Star of Bethlehem—and is led with attention to nuance, color and atmosphere by Chicago Opera Theater music director Lidiya Yankovskaya.

Through December 19, Studebaker Theater, 410 South Michigan, (312)753-3210, chicagooperatheater.org

Tagged:
  • Amy Owens
  • Chicago Opera Theater
  • David Salsbery Fry
  • Justin Berkowitz
  • Kyle Lang
  • Leah Dexter
  • Lidiya Yankovskaya
  • Mark Adamo
  • Martin Bakari
  • Matt Boehler
  • Nina Yoshida Nelson

Post navigation

Previous Post ‘Tis The Season: A Review of When Harry Met Rehab
Next Post Everything Is Beautiful: A Review of “8-Track: The Sounds of the ’70s” at Theo Ubique
Lawrence Edelson headshot

Kurt Weill’s “Der Silbersee” Gets Its Chicago Premiere Nearly a Century Later Chicago Opera Theater is staging the opera that premiered in Germany in 1933 before being banned by the Nazi party.

Ted C. Fishman February 25, 2026
Puppeteers set a scene with Ebenezer Scrooge

Stage Top 5: December 2025

Todd Hieggelke November 21, 2025
A woman stands on a stage set with a bus

Chicago Opera Theater’s “She Who Dared” Tells the Story of Pivotal Figures in Black Liberation

Teddy Sandler June 4, 2025

Double Freedom from Tyranny: A Review of “Fidelio” at Lyric Opera and “Leonora” at Chicago Opera Theater

Dennis Polkow October 4, 2024

A magazine cover split vertically: the left half shows wood grain, the right half shows a mans face and neck. NEWCITY and OCTOBER 2021 appear in yellow text at the top right.

October Issue
Realism

GET A COPY

SUBSCRIBE

White text in all capital letters on a light gray background spells NEWCITY..
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Chicago Film Project

Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc. © 2026