• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Newcity Stage

Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago

  • Newcity Stage ·
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Newcity Network
  • Sections ·
    • Newcity
    • Art
    • Design
    • Film
    • Lit
    • Music
    • Resto
    • Brazil
  • Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
Newcity Stage logo

Yippee Ki-Yay: A Review of The Virginian by City Lit Theatre

by Noel Schecter | January 20, 2022

by Noel Schecter
January 20, 2022January 18, 2022Filed under:
  • Recommended Shows
  • Theater Reviews

Robert Hunter Bry and Aaron Sarka in City Lit Theatre’s “The Virginian”/Photo: Steve Grace

RECOMMENDED

“The Virginian: A Horseman of the Plains” by Owen Wister is considered by many to be the first Western novel. Published in 1902, the book introduced to a wide audience what it means to be a cowboy (free-spirited but with a sense of duty; and, it goes without saying, white). It even featured the first literary Western showdown with the heroic Virginian (he has a name, but most folks call him by where he was born) gunning down his cowardly rival in a duel. Besides remaining in print for well over a century, Wister’s novel has been made into seven films (the most recent in 2014), as well as a television series that ran from 1962 to 1971. This production, adapted for the stage by L.C. Bernadine and Spencer Huffman and directed by City Lit artistic director Terry McCabe, as a whole appears to be a faithful adaptation of the source material. One key element to note is City Lit’s color-blind casting, which produces a more accurately diverse pre-statehood Wyoming than shown in a classic Western. It also effectively reinforces that nation-building was not done exclusively by white men.

The play also accurately showcases how common it was for men, even strangers, to share hotel beds (a detail I suspect that will never be included in an official Texas school history book). Life in the Wyoming Territory otherwise is depicted pretty much how one would expect it would be in early twentieth-century literature. The Virginian (a well-cast Robert Hunter Bry) has a code of honor befitting a knight. He is also a strong defender of capitalism, as witnessed by his angry response to a co-worker’s insistence that the cattle more rightfully belong to the cattle hands than the owner. It goes without saying that the new “schoolmarm” (Liz Falstreau) will eventually be smitten by his charms. There is, of course, also a villain (Ben Auxier at his most sinister) along with loyal, and less loyal, sidekicks who all seem destined to lay the framework for an eventually more civilized society.

Liz Falstreau (with a puppet horse) in City Lit Theatre’s “The Virginian”/Photo: Steve Graue

Accompanying the story for almost its entirety is the wonderful work of cellist and composer Kelsee Vandervall whose delicate playing perfectly replicates the feel of a classic Western. Credit also goes to Ray Toler’s understated but beautiful scenic design. I am, however, less certain about the herd of puppet horses created by The Puppet Company. While impressive in size (they are three-quarters the size of actual horses), they appear almost skeletal on stage, in large part because of their hollowed-out eyes.

City Lit, which has been adapting classic literature for the stage for more than forty seasons, clearly knows what it are doing—this production is a wonderful treat for those in love with Western literature.

City Lit Theater, 1020 West Bryn Mawr, (773)293-3682, $34. Through February 20.

Tagged:
  • Ben Auxier
  • City Lit Theater
  • Kelsee Vandervall
  • L.C. Bernadine
  • Liz Falstreau
  • Owen Wister
  • Ray Toler
  • Robert Hunter Bry
  • Spencer Huffman
  • Terry McCabe

Post navigation

Previous Post Things Don’t Have to Get Better: A Review of Wellesley Girl at Compass Theatre
Next Post Find the Funny: A Preview of Noah Gardenswartz at Zanies Chicago
A man dressed as a cowboy kneels on stage holding a revolver, wearing a brown coat and black hat, with a wooden saloon backdrop and dramatic lighting.

City Lit’s “Shane” Brings the Western Novel to the Stage Mark Pracht's adaptation of the 1949 book rewrites masculinity in a Western setting, with a phenomenal performance by lead Michael B. Woods.

Mary Wisniewski September 3, 2026
A group of actors in period costumes stand on stage, some raising bottles in a toast. The background features dramatic lighting, candles, and a painted backdrop, creating a theatrical and historical atmosphere.

“Scaramouche” Is a Swashbuckling Good Time The musical version of the classic novel makes its world debut at City Lit Theater, a comedy-adventure-romance mixed with dueling and song.

Mary Wisniewski May 13, 2026
A black and white photo of a person lying motionless on a table, partially covered by a sheet, in a dark and empty room. A spotlight illuminates the body, emphasizing a somber and dramatic atmosphere.

“The Shape of the Bones” Has Promise but Needs To Be Fleshed Out Playwright Spencer Huffman’s religious drama—and New Theatre Project’s first production in a conventional theater space—boasts some excellent performances in a story that doesn’t quite satisfy.

Hugh Iglarsh March 6, 2026
Three people sit on a white floor in front of a textured white backdrop. The person closest to the camera poses with one hand on the floor, while the other two sit cross-legged in the background, appearing contemplative.

“Kubrickian” Teeters Between Cosmic Drama and Spacey Oddity Factory Theater’s overlong production has its moments, but it struggles to pull us into its sci-fi scenario.

Hugh Iglarsh February 27, 2026

Newcity cover showing woman with red hair and bird-face, with nest and crow on top of head.

September Issue
Fall Arts + Art 50

GET A COPY

SUBSCRIBE

NewcityLogo.png
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Chicago Film Project

Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc. © 2026